Skip to content

Retail sales

Sales Broker, Personal Lines

Mitch Insurance Brokers logoMitch Insurance BrokersToronto, Ontario, CanadaFull-timeListed 7mo ago

Tools for this application (partners): JobSeeker (opens in new tab) (resume) · Huntr (opens in new tab) (tracking) · Huru (opens in new tab) (interview practice) · Prospeo (opens in new tab) (hiring manager's email) · Aragon AI (opens in new tab) (headshot) · Terac (opens in new tab) (side work) what each does

The posting

Personal Lines Sales Broker

Mitch is a leading insurance brokerage on a mission to make insurance lovable through exceptional experiences.  We’ve  been recognized as Brokerage and Innovator of the  Year, and  have been named one of Canada’s Top Growing Companies by The Globe and Mail’s Report on Business magazine multiple times.

We’re growing our Personal Lines sales team to take our client experience to the next level and elevate Mitch to new heights. Are you a high-performing Sales Broker who puts clients first, closes with confidence, and always looks for opportunities to raise the bar? Join us!

What you’ll do

As a Personal Lines Sales Broker at Mitch , you’ll work with leads we generate , gi ving you a pipeline of prospects who are actively shopping for insurance and are ready to engage.

U sing our proven playbook, you’ll uncover prospects’ needs and provide guidance on the different solutions available . You’ll have access to products from over 70 insurance companies and a streamlined sales process designed for speed, accuracy, and volume – so you can focus on building relationships and helping clients choose coverages that are right for them.

You take pride in your professionalism and expertise , and you’re continually looking for ways to refine your skills to elevat e both your impact and the value you provide.

What you’re amazing at

  • Selling consultatively by listening first, asking thoughtful questions, and recommending coverage solutions that truly fit client needs
  • Naturally moving conversation s forward , t urning objections into opportunities , and confidently closing every sale
  • Working quickly and accurately across multiple systems while keeping clients engaged
  • Taking full ownership of your performance and maintaining a high standard of accountability
  • Operating with integrity in every interaction with clients, teammates, and carriers while strengthening your reputation as a trusted advisor
  • Adhering to all underwriting guidelines and compliance requirements
  • Keeping up with products, industry trends, and market conditions to provide clients with up-to-date insights
  • Staying positive and thriving under pressure

Your qualifications You’ve worked as a Personal Lines Sales Broker at an insurance brokerage for at least one year and have deep knowledge of Personal Lines products. You also have your RIBO licen c e .

Compensation

We offer a c ommission-based compensation plan with an annual base salary of $5 0,000 – $ 60,000 and on-target total earnings of up to $140,000 for brokers closing 60 policies per month. Brokers who exceed that benchmark are compensated accordingly. There are no caps or ceilings – the more you produce, the more you earn .

Where  you’ll  work is up to you We believe in providing a flexible work environment where our teammates have the  option  to work for us from anywhere across Canada.

Come join us We have very big plans and are on an exciting path to the future. If you want to help bring game-changing ideas to life and make a difference, then join us on our mission to make insurance lovable.

Mitch is an equal opportunity employer, and we’re committed to building an inclusive, diverse, and inspiring environment for all employees. If you require any specific accommodations during the recruitment process, please let us know and we’ll be happy to work with you to meet your needs.

Taken from Mitch Insurance Brokers's own posting, last seen live on 14 Nov 2026.

Mitch Insurance Brokers sales openings in your inbox

We look at Mitch Insurance Brokers's careers page every 10 hours. Once a week you get its newest sales openings, plus close matches at other companies. Free, and one click stops it.

Sponsored

Sponsored jobs from job networks, which pay SalesJobs.Now when you click one.

About Mitch Insurance Brokers

A family-owned Ontario insurance brokerage (Mitchell & Whale until its rename) that places auto, home, motorcycle, business, cyber, life and other cover for households and small and mid-sized businesses with more than 70 Canadian insurers.

Pay schedule: Base salary plus uncapped commission for the sales brokers, salary advances against commission (a draw) for the commercial producer, and base plus commission or bonus for the account managers, all with the option of working remotely from anywhere in Canada.

Selling on a store floor or in customers' homes?

Hiring managers ask us for sellers with a certain segment, territory or track record. Fill in one profile, and when a seat matches it we make the introduction, never without your yes. It costs you nothing.

Build my profile