Skip to content
American Fidelity logo

American Fidelity

About American Fidelity

American Fidelity's field force sells voluntary benefits at the workplace: disability income, life and supplemental health cover, retirement and annuity products and benefits services, offered to the employees of K-12 public school districts and, in a separate business market, to the staff of employers such as auto dealerships, healthcare facilities and public bodies. The seller is a salaried career account manager, posted as outside sales representative, sales representative or sales account manager, who takes over a defined territory with an existing customer base, must live in it, travels overnight across it and grows it through annual benefit enrollments, group presentations, one-on-one meetings with employees and new district or employer accounts, working with school administrators and teachers' associations along the way. School territories run state by state across the West, the Midwest and the South, while the business-market account managers hold territories in Illinois and Indiana. New hires go through a structured program of on-the-job training in the territory, product and sales schools and online courses; postings ask for sales or leadership experience or a recent graduate who led in college, prefer few job changes, and run financial, criminal and driving record checks, and an Oklahoma territory asks for a seasoned seller. Around the territories sit an account service coordinator in Salt Lake City who services school accounts and sells to them, a senior account relations coordinator for large employer groups in Alabama, and an AI sales solutions partner in the Oklahoma City home office who brings AI tools to the sales force.

Stated per posting

Stated by the company

, SalesJobs.Now shows 35 open American Fidelity sales roles.

American Fidelity sales openings

Board read 16 Nov 2026, 19:08 UTC

Comparable sales openings elsewhere

The same sales role at other companies.

If one of these employers pays a referral fee, it comes from them when you apply here, and your offer stays exactly the same.

Comparable sales openings elsewhere

If one of these employers pays a referral fee, it comes from them when you apply here, and your offer stays exactly the same.

SalesJobs.Now is free for job seekers. Some links here pay us: a job ad network pays for a click on one of its sponsored jobs, a recruiting firm pays a referral fee when someone who came from here is hired, and a career tool pays a commission when you buy it. That costs you nothing and never lowers what you are paid. Roles whose links pay us can be placed higher in a list. "Featured roles" are openings an employer picked during a free trial with us; no employer can pay for that spot.

Sponsored

Sponsored jobs from job networks, which pay SalesJobs.Now when you click one.

American Fidelity openings by country

Where its sales openings take applicants, country by country.

American Fidelity sales openings in your inbox

We look at American Fidelity's careers page every 6 hours. Once a week you get its newest sales openings, plus close matches at other companies. Free, and one click stops it.

American Fidelity as an employer

Family-owned Oklahoma City insurer, founded in 1960, whose sales hiring is salaried territory account managers selling worksite benefits to school districts and employers. Posted pay: Stated per posting (stated by the company).

35 sales openings on its careers board right now
Hiring right now

35 sales openings at American Fidelity, as its own board showed them 16 Nov 2026.

How pay is built

Salaried career account managers earn a base salary plus uncapped commission and bonus, with a company car, paid travel, a 401(k) match and sales award trips.

Where it hires

Right now its 35 open sales roles are posted in Illinois (3), Michigan (3), Oklahoma City (3), Indiana (2), Montana (2) and 14 more places, and 7 are remote. Read from its postings on 16 Nov 2026: US only: school territories in Alabama (Montgomery, Dothan), Alaska (Anchorage, Fairbanks), Arizona (Phoenix, Mesa, Chandler, Tempe, Scottsdale, Gilbert), Arkansas (Little Rock), Southern California (Riverside, San Bernardino, Los Angeles, Glendale, Ventura, Santa Barbara), Colorado (Grand Junction), Florida (Miami), Idaho (Boise, Coeur d'Alene), Indiana (Evansville), Michigan (Grand Rapids, Kalamazoo, Saginaw), Missouri (Kansas City), Montana (Billings, Helena), Nevada (Las Vegas), Ohio (Columbus, Akron, Dayton, Zanesville), Oklahoma (Oklahoma City, Norman), Oregon (Portland, Salem, Eugene, Medford), Pennsylvania (Pittsburgh, Philadelphia), Utah (Salt Lake City, Ogden, Provo) and Illinois; business-market territories around Springfield, Peoria, Champaign and Bloomington, Illinois, and Fort Wayne, South Bend and Muncie, Indiana; the home office in Oklahoma City.

Caveats

  • The pay figure is stated by the company: a reference point from research, not a salary read off today's postings, so negotiate from the offer in front of you.

Pay at American Fidelity

Stated by the company, checked 2026-11-16
Stated per posting

From our research: stated by the company, checked 16 Nov 2026

Read from its postings on 16 Nov 2026: American Fidelity's sales postings describe the pay as a base salary plus uncapped commission and bonus potential, and instead of a base range they print an expected first-year income band, called an average on some postings and a potential on others. Territory seats add a company car (with a gas card in the business market), a company credit card and paid travel, a 401(k) match and international sales award trips. The account service coordinator posting is the one that states its base, beside uncapped commission and a lower first-year income band. No account manager posting gives the base alone or says how commission is earned (new premium, renewals or enrollments), so ask for the base, the commission schedule and how much of the first-year figure comes from the book you take over. The roles listed below state what American Fidelity posts now.

Method: how we research and grade employer pay.

Sales roles American Fidelity hires for

Click a role to see what the job involves, which companies want it and what it posts for pay everywhere.

Breaking into sales? Read the guides first or see what every company posts for pay.

From the forum

Ask salespeople what American Fidelity is like from the inside: comp, quota, the interview loop.

Ask about American Fidelity

American Fidelity: what candidates ask before applying

Is American Fidelity a good company to sell for?

Family-owned Oklahoma City insurer, founded in 1960, whose sales hiring is salaried territory account managers selling worksite benefits to school districts and employers.

Is American Fidelity still an active employer?

Yes. Family-owned Oklahoma City insurer, founded in 1960, whose sales hiring is salaried territory account managers selling worksite benefits to school districts and employers. How its pay is structured: Salaried career account managers earn a base salary plus uncapped commission and bonus, with a company car, paid travel, a 401(k) match and sales award trips.

What does a sales job at American Fidelity pay?

Stated per posting. American Fidelity's sales postings describe the pay as a base salary plus uncapped commission and bonus potential, and instead of a base range they print an expected first-year income band, called an average on some postings and a potential on others. Territory seats add a company car (with a gas card in the business market), a company credit card and paid travel, a 401(k) match and international sales award trips. The account service coordinator posting is the one that states its base, beside uncapped commission and a lower first-year income band. No account manager posting gives the base alone or says how commission is earned (new premium, renewals or enrollments), so ask for the base, the commission schedule and how much of the first-year figure comes from the book you take over.

Is selling for American Fidelity worth it?

Posted pay at American Fidelity: Stated per posting (stated by the company). Insurance sales suit reps who can explain coverage plainly, work patiently with brokers and keep a book of renewals growing.

How is American Fidelity's sales comp put together?

Salaried career account managers earn a base salary plus uncapped commission and bonus, with a company car, paid travel, a 401(k) match and sales award trips.

Where are American Fidelity's sales roles based?

Right now its 35 open sales roles are posted in Illinois (3), Michigan (3), Oklahoma City (3), Indiana (2), Montana (2) and 14 more places, and 7 are remote. Read from its postings on 16 Nov 2026: US only: school territories in Alabama (Montgomery, Dothan), Alaska (Anchorage, Fairbanks), Arizona (Phoenix, Mesa, Chandler, Tempe, Scottsdale, Gilbert), Arkansas (Little Rock), Southern California (Riverside, San Bernardino, Los Angeles, Glendale, Ventura, Santa Barbara), Colorado (Grand Junction), Florida (Miami), Idaho (Boise, Coeur d'Alene), Indiana (Evansville), Michigan (Grand Rapids, Kalamazoo, Saginaw), Missouri (Kansas City), Montana (Billings, Helena), Nevada (Las Vegas), Ohio (Columbus, Akron, Dayton, Zanesville), Oklahoma (Oklahoma City, Norman), Oregon (Portland, Salem, Eugene, Medford), Pennsylvania (Pittsburgh, Philadelphia), Utah (Salt Lake City, Ogden, Provo) and Illinois; business-market territories around Springfield, Peoria, Champaign and Bloomington, Illinois, and Fort Wayne, South Bend and Muncie, Indiana; the home office in Oklahoma City.

Weigh American Fidelity against

An ICHRA benefits platform that gives each employee a monthly health budget to buy their own insurance plan and spend the rest on care, sold to employers of every size, largely through benefits brokers and consultants.

$165k–$300k/yrTypical pay, live

Auto, home, renters, life, health and small business insurance, plus mutual funds and annuities, sold to households and business owners through its independent contractor agents across the US.

$200k/yrTypical pay, live

A life insurer owned by its policyowners, selling life, disability income and annuity products and workplace voluntary benefits through its own financial advisors and through broker-dealers, banks and other distribution firms.

Stated per postingStated by the company

Sells commercial insurance (general liability, commercial auto, property, cyber, umbrella and bonds) to small businesses, with AI doing intake and quoting and licensed people closing.

$138k–$208k/yrTypical pay, live

Companies are listed by what an application there is worth to you, and one that pays us a fee for hires sent from here gets a lift in that order; the fee never touches the base or OTE a company offers.

Hiring salespeople at American Fidelity? See how to put your openings in front of the sellers who browse this board.